Check out this answer from Consensus:

The synthesis of research indicates that intelligence is shaped by both genetic and environmental factors. Genetic predispositions provide a foundation, but environmental influences, including cultural and educational contexts, play a crucial role in the development and expression of cognitive abilities. The interactionist perspective, which views nature and nurture as interdependent, offers a more comprehensive understanding of the determinants of intelligence.

The debate over whether intelligence is primarily influenced by genetic factors (nature) or environmental factors (nurture) has been a longstanding and complex issue in psychology and genetics. This synthesis aims to present key insights from various research papers to provide a clearer understanding of the contributions of nature and nurture to intelligence.

Key Insights

• Genetic Influence on Intelligence:

  • Intelligence is significantly influenced by genetic factors, with individual differences largely determined by genetics1 2 4.

  • Advances in molecular genetics have identified specific genes that influence cognitive abilities and disabilities, highlighting the genetic basis of intelligence2 7.

• Environmental Influence on Intelligence:

  • Environmental factors also play a crucial role in shaping intelligence, with cultural and educational contexts significantly impacting cognitive development3 7 8.

  • The interaction between genetic predispositions and environmental factors (genotype-environment covariance) suggests that the environment can enhance or suppress genetic potentials3 8.

• Heritability and Cultural Load:

  • Heritability coefficients for intelligence vary across different cognitive abilities, with culture-loaded subtests showing higher heritability than culture-reduced subtests. This indicates that culturally influenced abilities may have a stronger genetic component3.

• Historical Perspectives and Shifts:

  • Historically, the debate has seen shifts in focus, with early researchers like Francis Galton emphasizing genetic dominance, while more recent studies acknowledge the significant role of environmental factors4 6.

  • The complexity of disentangling genetic and environmental influences has led some researchers to view the nature-nurture debate as an oversimplification, advocating for a more integrated approach6 10.

• Modern Perspectives and Integration:

  • Contemporary research emphasizes the interactionist perspective, where both genetic and environmental factors are seen as interdependent and mutually influential in the development of intelligence8 9.

  • The role of human agency and epigenetic factors further complicates the simple dichotomy of nature versus nurture, suggesting that intelligence results from a dynamic interplay of multiple factors8.